Published on Sociology & Anthropology (https://socioanthro.uoguelph.ca)

Home > Miscarriages of Justice (SOC*4330)

Miscarriages of Justice (SOC*4330)

Course code: 
SOC*4330
Section: 
01
Course term: 
Winter 2025
Course instructor: 
Carolyn Yule
Details: 

Course Description:
The purpose of this course is to provide a critical and interdisciplinary examination of the current functioning of the Canadian criminal justice system. We will explore procedures used by various criminal justice actors to assess their potential for producing errors in justice. We will consider the implications of balancing the rights of the accused with crime control and examine the retributive aims of the system for victims and society-at-large. While the content of this course focuses on wrongful convictions, it is not one-sided. A broad definition of ‘justice’ requires that we consider the implications of both convicting the innocent and neglecting to convict the guilty. The focus of scholarship on wrongful convictions is relatively new, yet a wealth of factors have been identified as contributing to miscarriages of justice. This course will canvass the international literature, but will focus more heavily on recent Canadian developments.

Course Goals and Learning Objectives:
The main learning objectives for this course include:
• Identify sociological, psychological, legal, scientific, and psychological factors that contribute to miscarriages of justice, broadly defined.
• Examine the role of the police, crown, defence, witnesses, and the judiciary in contributing to unintended consequences like the wrongful apprehension, prosecution, conviction, and incarceration of the innocent.
• Reveal the psychological, familial, emotional, and economic consequences of wrongful convictions.
• Explore the collateral consequences of punishing “false positives,” including implications for undermining the legitimacy of the criminal justice system and allowing impunity for culpable offenders who remain at-large.
• Consider existing redress mechanisms to remedy miscarriages of justice and provide suggestions for policy change.

Course Readings: Available on Courselink

(Tentative) Assessment/Evaluation:
Quizzes………………………................................................15%
Collaborative Seminar Presentation…………….…………..20%
Research proposal………………………………………..………….10%
Term Paper (12-15 pages) ……………………………….……...25%
Take-Home Final Assignment…………………………………..10%
Class Participation …………………..…………………..............20%

Class Format:
This is an advanced seminar course. As such, student participation is expected and encouraged. I expect that you will be prepared for class by reading the assigned material prior to class and actively participating in discussion during class time for the entire semester. I will supplement the course with films and guest lectures to facilitate the application of course material.
***Please note: I reserve the right to make changes to the outline as posted. I will provide a complete course outline on the first day of class.

About the College

The College of Social and Applied Human Sciences traces its origins and traditions to the establishment of the Macdonald Institute, one of the University of Guelph's three founding colleges.

The college provides programming in a range of social science and applied human science disciplines and support to discipline-based and interdisciplinary researchers.

Academic Departments

Family Relations & Applied Nutrition
Geography, Environment & Geomatics
Political Science
Psychology
Sociology & Anthropology

Institutes & Other Units

Canada India Research Centre for Learning and Engagement (CIRCLE)
Community Engaged Scholarship Institute (CESI)
Criminal Justice and Public Policy
Guelph Institute of Development Studies
The Live Work Well Research Centre
ReVision: The Centre for Art and Social Justice

Contact

College of Social & Applied Human Sciences
University of Guelph
50 Stone Road East
Guelph, Ontario,
N1G 2W1
Canada

Email: csahs@uoguelph.ca
Tel: 519-824-4120 x56753
Fax: 519-766-4797


Source URL:https://socioanthro.uoguelph.ca/course-outlines/miscarriages-justice-soc4330-1